top of page
Search

Isekai's last whimpers as a genre.

The premise never gets old, a grey haired, black eyed, husk of a personality, disgruntled office worker gets truck-kun'd, wakes up in a fantasy world with overpowered abilities! Isekai, meaning "other world," has exploded in popularity. Light novels churn out endless variations, and anime studios can't seem to get enough of them.But honestly, i fail to believe they're primarily based on Light novels these days.

There's a sense of déjà vu with most Isekai. The overpowered protagonist with zero social skills surrounded by a harem of attractive female companions feels like a tired trope, and it's gotten more generic and less creative as the years go.  Worlds often borrow heavily from Western fantasy or generic RPG mechanics, lacking the originality that drew viewers in the first place. Not that you can't do them originally, like Overlord, Sword Art Online, Reincarnated as a Slime, et-cetera.

The thrill of a new world gets buried under mountains of explanation. Characters spend episodes explaining basic magic systems or repeating plot points we just witnessed. It's not even original, yet they want to spend episodes explaining how to "Level-up"?It's like the writers don't trust the audience to keep up, let alone guess what it's based upon from the mountain of other anime we've already watched resorting to narration that treats viewers like morons.


The pacing can be brutal. Episodes drag with endless build-up to reveals that amount to "the hero levels up again!" Cliffhangers become a crutch, strung together with minimal tension to keep viewers hooked, even through year long breaks. The fat and lard filled CEO's sit and watch for money to crumble in for a second season.

Humor often relies on slapstick or the "comedy of stupidity." Side characters exist solely to admire the protagonist or spout ridiculous catchphrases, or sometimes they just avoid humor entirely, boiling down to "haha woman hit MC".


Action sequences are all bark and no bite. Flashy animation techniques mask a lack of choreography or emotional weight. The battles feel like empty spectacles compared to the genuine tension found in other genres, not to mention i don't think i see anyone really die either. There is zero tension, zero investment, zero interest, yet tasteless viewers gobble it up all the same because it works.


Some argue the light novel format, where internal monologues are common, doesn't translate well to anime. Long stretches of voice-over explanation become tedious, further dragging down the pacing.

There are, of course, exceptions. Shows like "Saga of Tanya the Evil" and "Mushoku Tensei", the father of all modern Isekai, prove the genre can still deliver fresh stories and captivating characters. But the sheer volume of mediocre Isekai churned out creates a sense of fatigue. Hopefully, creators will push the boundaries and rediscover the magic that first drew audiences to these "other worlds."Hell, just tell the fucking directors to stop eating lead and read some original Light Novels for once.Anyways, just wanted to rant. Cya.

 
 
 

1 Comment


Okiron
Okiron
Apr 22, 2024

I LIVE

Like
bottom of page